Are you considering ordering a custom sports jersey online and wondering whether Athleticastyle.com (a.k.a. Athenastyle) is legit, reliable, or too good to be true? This detailed review analyzes 69 Trustpilot reviews, independent scam‑checkers, and Reddit insights to help you decide.
What Is Athleticastyle.com?
Athleticastyle.com (operating as Athenastyle) sells custom replica jerseys (NFL, NBA, MLB, college teams) with personalized names, numbers, and patches. They promote fast delivery and low prices, positioning themselves as a budget-friendly alternative to licensed team stores.
According to Trustpilot, the site holds a TrustScore of 4.0 out of 5 based on 69 reviews.
Check it out here:
https://www.trustpilot.com/review/athenastyle.com
Customer Review Highlights
Recent 2025 Feedback (May–June 2025)
Positive Experiences:
- “Would buy again! Custom options were easy to use… thick material… pro‑level feel.” — Moriah Mcpadden, May 28, 2025
- “Love this jersey… great material, clean stitching… super detailed.” — Gary Rascon, May 29, 2025
- “Ordered a USC college football jersey… pleasantly surprised… delivery took longer but excellent quality.” — Frank C., June 2, 2025
Negative Experiences:
- “Pre‑order filled with wrong player number (used old college number)… no replacement offered.” — Daniel T., June 3, 2025
- “Received youth size instead of women’s. Multiple requests for correction ignored.” — Carol Crago, June 5, 2025
- “Poor quality, faded lettering, loose threads… XXL fits like XL.” — James Martinez, April 18, 2025
You can view these reviews directly here:
https://www.trustpilot.com/review/athenastyle.com
Older Reviews (2023–2024)
- March 2024: Morgan Wallen jersey mistakenly shipped as “MALLEN,” customer service ghosted the buyer — delivery took up to six months. “They suck.”
- Sizing complaints: “Took 6 weeks… cheap fabric, poor fit, loose threads everywhere.” — Lauren Qualizza, May 7, 2024
- Youth size shipped instead of adult, no response to repeated emails.
See these and other older reviews here:
https://ie.trustpilot.com/review/athenastyle.com
Scam Risk & Trustworthiness
Scam Analysis Tools
- Scamadviser flags some review irregularities and advises verifying reviews manually:
https://www.scamadviser.com/check-website/athenastyle.com - Safelyweb rates the site moderately safe with hosting details:
https://safelyweb.com/other/athenastyle.com
Reddit Community Feedback
- Some Reddit users call the Trustpilot reviews suspicious, accusing the company of review manipulation:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Realorfake/comments/1584ckm
Pros & Cons Summary
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Very affordable custom jerseys with stitched patches and logos | Inconsistent sizing—especially larger sizes |
| Several buyers report premium feel and accurate customization | Pre‑orders sometimes filled incorrectly (wrong player number) |
| Some responsive customer service resolutions noted | Poor quality on some items—faded colors, loose threads |
| Delivery typically 2–3 weeks for many orders | Reports of never receiving items, failed refunds, or ghosting |
Is Athleticastyle.com Legit?
Yes and no. It’s not a traditional scam—the company delivers jerseys to most customers. However, many buyers describe order errors, long delays, and poor support. Trustpilot’s mixed credibility and third-party warnings suggest you should proceed with caution.
Tips If You’re Considering Ordering
- Review sizing charts carefully and allow room for possible variation.
- Record all customization and order confirmations (screenshots/emails).
- Avoid pre-orders for newly drafted players—mistakes here are common.
- Use a payment method with buyer protection like PayPal or credit cards.
- Check your spam folder—customer queries may be answered there.
Final Verdict
Athleticastyle.com (Athenastyle) may offer good value if you’re willing to accept some risk. Many customers receive well‑made, detailed jerseys at low cost. However, others encounter sizing issues, wrong items, or stuck orders. Review history is highly polarized, making each purchase a gamble.
SEO Keywords Included in This Post
- Athleticastyle.com review
- Athenastyle custom jerseys
- Athenastyle Trustpilot
- Athleticastyle scam or legit
- buy replica sports jerseys online
Click here to see other websites that we have written on.
